Don’t disrupt the House of debate
India’s parliamentary democracy faces challenges like frequent disruptions and declining debate quality, which undermine public trust. Maintaining decorum, encouraging dialogue, and building consensus are crucial for effective governance.
|
Role, Importance, and Working of Parliament
1. Role:
- Supreme Legislative Body : Enacts laws for governance.
- Deliberative Forum: Debates critical national and international issues.
- Representation: Reflects the will and aspirations of the people.
- Accountability Mechanism: Holds the executive accountable through questions, motions, and committees.
2. Importance:
- Democratic Bedrock: Ensures government functions transparently and responsibly.
- Policy Formulation: Addresses socio-economic challenges through informed discussions.
- Safeguarding Rights: Protects citizens’ fundamental rights and ensures justice.
3. Working:
- Sessions: Regular sessions (Budget, Monsoon, Winter) to transact business.
- Committees: Specialized committees enhance efficiency and scrutinize issues.
- Debate and Discussion: Encourages healthy discourse to shape policies.
- Checks and Balances: Maintains balance between the legislature, executive, and judiciary.
|
Current Challenges
- Frequent Disruptions and Unruly Behavior: Instances of members rushing to the well of the House, shouting slogans, snatching papers, and even climbing desks have overshadowed meaningful discussions.
- These actions violate procedural norms, disrupting legislative processes and tarnishing the reputation of Parliament.
- Decline in Constructive Deliberations: Constant high-decibel sloganeering and acrimonious debates have replaced substantive discussions on pressing socio-economic issues. This erosion of debate undermines the core of democratic decision-making.
- Obstructionist Tactics: Boycotts, walkouts, and confrontations with presiding officers reflect a lack of willingness to engage constructively. Such actions often create legislative stalemates, hindering governance and policy formulation.
Impacts of Parliamentary Dysfunction
- Public Disillusionment: Disruptions breed cynicism and disillusionment among citizens, evidenced by declining voter turnout and a growing distrust in democratic institutions.
- People perceive Parliament as failing to address their concerns, further alienating the electorate.
- Economic Costs: Parliamentary disruptions incur significant costs, including staff salaries and operational expenses, making these episodes a financial burden on the public exchequer.
- Global Image and Credibility: As a beacon of democracy and a fast-growing economy, India’s global stature could be compromised by a dysfunctional Parliament.
- Inefficiency undermines India’s credibility and its leadership role on the international stage.
Recommendations for Improvement
- Promoting Constructive Dialogue: Political parties must commit to fostering a culture of debate and discussion, avoiding unnecessary disruptions.
- Dialogue should be marked by mutual respect and a willingness to engage across party lines.
- Ensuring Accountability and Integrity: Political parties must enforce stricter norms for member conduct, emphasizing integrity and procedural adherence. Ethical behavior must be a priority for current and aspiring leaders.
- Consensus-Building Across Party Lines: A collective commitment to consensual politics is essential for addressing critical national issues.
- This requires a spirit of give-and-take, with the government welcoming constructive criticism and the opposition refraining from obstructionist tactics.
- Drawing Inspiration from Parliamentary Icons: Aspiring leaders should emulate stalwarts like Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Hiren Mukherjee, whose decorum and dedication to democratic principles set high benchmarks for legislative conduct.
- Strengthening Procedural Mechanisms: Measures such as stricter penalties for unruly behavior and mandatory training on parliamentary procedures can help restore decorum and efficiency.
The decline in parliamentary standards is a wake-up call for all political players to rise above their differences and work towards a more inclusive and responsive governance framework. By collectively committing to constructive dialogue and ethical behavior, political parties can uphold the sanctity of Indian democracy and strengthen its foundation for future generations.
Next
previous
Latest News
EDITORIALS & ARTICLES
General Studies