- Home
- Prelims
- Mains
- Current Affairs
- Study Materials
- Test Series
Examine the role of science and technology in addressing age-old taboos and superstitions. (UPSC CSE Mains 2023 - Sociology, Paper 1)
Taboos and superstitions have historically been cultural mechanisms to understand the unexplained. Science and technology have played a pivotal role in challenging and addressing age-old taboos and superstitions. Sociological thinkers from both Western and Indian perspectives have contributed valuable insights into this transformative process.
- Durkheim believed that modern societies, with their focus on science and reason, would naturally diminish the prevalence of superstitions.
- August Comte proposed that positivist sociology could replace religious beliefs and superstitions with rational and empirical knowledge.
- Weber''s concept of the "disenchantment of the world" highlighted the rationalization and secularization of society through science and technology.
Role of Science
- Demystifying Phenomena: Bronisław Malinowski argued that magic and superstition filled gaps where knowledge was lacking, a gap that science progressively fills. Example: Solar eclipses, once viewed with fear and superstition, are now understood as natural astronomical events.
- Medical Advancements: Emile Durkheim emphasized how pre-scientific societies used collective representations like taboos to make sense of such illnesses. Example: Epilepsy, previously considered a spiritual possession, is now known to be a neurological disorder.
- Promotion of Rational Thought: Science promotes critical thinking, questioning of established norms, and evidence-based understanding. Karl Popper''s philosophy of science argues for falsifiability and the continuous questioning of knowledge.
Role of Technology
- Dissemination of Knowledge: Marshall McLuhan''s "global village" concept underlines how technology shrinks spatial barriers, allowing for rapid knowledge exchange. Example: Mobile apps explaining the science behind natural events, challenging traditional myths.
- Fostering Dialogue: Online campaigns addressing and debunking myths related to menstrual taboos. Jürgen Habermas’s idea of the "public sphere" is exemplified in these digital spaces where public opinion is shaped.
- Archiving and Research: Technology aids in documenting various superstitions and taboos, facilitating academic research.
Limitations
Despite successes, there are limitations of science and technology in addressing age-old taboos and superstitions:
- Cultural Resistance: Deeply ingrained cultural beliefs may resist the influence of science and technology, making it challenging to eradicate superstitions.
- Misinformation and Pseudoscience: The internet also spreads misinformation and pseudoscience, leading to the creation of new superstitions. Example: Social media can amplify false claims, such as those related to "miracle" cures.
- Digital Divide: The digital divide can hinder access to scientific information, perpetuating superstitions among marginalized communities.
- Limited Infrastructure: Rural areas may lack the necessary technological infrastructure, hindering access to scientific knowledge. Example: Remote villages in India may lack internet connectivity and healthcare facilities.
- Economic Barriers: Access to advanced healthcare and educational technologies can be limited by economic disparities, reinforcing superstitions among the poor.
- Emotional Attachments: People often have emotional attachments to superstitions, making it difficult to abandon them, even in the face of scientific evidence.
- Traditional Healers and Practices: Traditional healers and practices can have a strong hold on communities, resisting efforts to replace them with science-based alternatives.
While science and technology play a pivotal role in addressing age-old taboos and superstitions, it''s essential to approach the process with cultural sensitivity. Ensuring inclusive access to scientific knowledge and leveraging technology ethically can pave the way for a society where beliefs are more in harmony with empirical realities.