EDITORIALS & ARTICLES

France’s New Prime Minister

President Emmanuel Macron named close ally Sébastien Lecornu as the new French Prime Minister, a day after a confidence vote in parliament removed François Bayrou from the post.

  • The French Constitution (1958): France operates under the Constitution of the Fifth Republic, drafted in 1958. It establishes a semi-presidential system, with power shared between the directly elected President and the appointed Prime Minister.
  • French Parliament: France has a bicameral legislature, consisting of:
    • National Assembly (Assemblée Nationale), the directly elected lower house, with members (deputies) chosen through a two-round electoral system for five years. It holds primary law-making power and can bring down the government through no-confidence motions.
    • Senate (Sénat), the upper house, indirectly elected by local officials. It reviews legislation but does not control the government.

Selection Procedure of Prime Minister of France

  • Presidential Appointment (Article 8): The President of France has the power to appoint the Prime Minister.
  • Support from the National Assembly: Even though the President chooses the PM, the PM must have support in the National Assembly (the lower house of Parliament).
    • If the President’s party has a majority, he/she usually appoints a PM from his own party.
    • If the opposition controls the Assembly, the President must appoint a PM from that group (this is called cohabitation).
  • No-Confidence Motion (Article 49): The National Assembly can remove the PM through a vote of no-confidence. If this happens, the PM must resign.
  • Tenure: The PM does not have a fixed term. He continues in office as long as he has both the President’s support and the confidence of the National Assembly.

Comparative Analysis with India

  • Direct vs. Indirect Legitimacy: In India, the PM’s authority flows directly from legislative majority. In France, legitimacy rests on presidential appointment balanced by legislative acceptance.
  • Stability vs. Flexibility: India’s parliamentary system generally provides stability, though critics warn of excessive concentration of power under majority governments.
    • France’s semi-presidential design balances power but can produce frequent PM changes when no party secures a stable majority.
  • Role of Head of State: The Indian President acts on convention, while the French President wields real discretion in selecting and dismissing PMs.

Appointment of Prime Minister of India
– Article 75 of the Constitution of India stipulates that the Prime Minister shall be appointed by the President.
– By convention of the parliamentary system, the President is required to appoint the leader of the majority party in the Lok Sabha as the Prime Minister.
1. In the absence of a clear majority, the President may exercise limited discretion.
– In such circumstances, it is customary for the President to invite the leader of the largest party or coalition in the Lok Sabha to form the government, subject to securing a vote of confidence in the House within one month.

Similarities between the Constitution of India and France 

  • France became a republic from a monarchy following the French Revolution.
    • India was inspired by the French revolution. Tipu Sultan, the ruler of Mysore in the late eighteenth century, planted the Tree of Liberty in his capital Seringapatam and called himself ''Citizen Tipoo''. 
  • Since then, France has had numerous constitutions over the last two centuries, and the current one is the Fifth Republic, adopted in 1958. 
    • The First Republic came into existence in 1793 following the French Revolution, the Second in 1848, the Third in 1875, and the Fourth in 1946.
  • Both the countries have a written constitution which is based on the Ideals liberty, equality and fraternity outlined in French Revolution. 
  • Both the countries have popular sovereignty wherein citizens enjoy ''universals adult franchise''.
  • Both the Countries have a Bicameral Parliament. 
    • In France, Members of Lower House (National Assembly) are elected by direct universal suffrage for five years whereas Members of Upper House (Senate) are elected through indirect universal suffrage and renewable by half every three years.
  • Provision of emergency is also enshrined in the Constitution of both the countries. 

Contrasting Features of Constitution of India and France 

Specification 

India 

France 

Mechanism of expressing Popular Sovereignty

People exercise their sovereignty through their representatives

People exercise their sovereignty through their representatives and by means of referendum.

President is the Head of the State

The President is elected indirectly for a period of five years.

There is no limit on the number of terms of the President.

The President is elected for a term of five years by direct universal suffrage.

No one may carry out more than two consecutive terms of office

System of Government

Parliamentary: Parliamentary form of government which is federal in structure with certain unitary features. 

Semi-Presidential System: system features both a President (elected by universal direct suffrage) and a Prime minister, with the President having substantial powers. 

Prime Minister is Head of the Government 

  • The Constitution provides for the Council of Ministers Headed by the Prime Minister to aid and advise the President. 
  • Strength, roles and Responsibilities of Council of Ministers is provided in the Constitution. 
  • The President appoints the Prime Minister and the members of the government (on the recommendation of the Prime Minister).
  • The purview, competences, responsibilities and tasks of each minister are not fixed.  They are freely determined by the Prime Minister and the President.

Justice system

 

  • Integrated judicial system, meaning that the decisions made by higher courts are binding on the lower courts. 
  • Also, the appellate system exists in India.

Judicial authorities are divided into distinct entities between the legal jurisdictions responsible for settling disputes between individuals, and the administrative jurisdictions for disputes between citizens and the public authorities.

Involvement of Civil Society 

No provision 

Constitution provides for Economic, Social and Environmental Council (CESE), a consultative assembly, whose primary purpose is to get civil society involved in the government''s economic, social and environmental policies.

 







POSTED ON 12-09-2025 BY ADMIN
Next