Ethics - Case Study - Amit is an officer in charge of handling charges against corruption in health department. One day he receives a complaint alleging widespread irregularities in distributing free medicines to poor. Upon investigation, it is found that Amit’s boss is the main culprit behind the corruption. Amit confronts his boss regarding the charges and demands clarifications. Instead of denying charges, boss asks Amit to bury the evidences and in return Amit will be promoted. Amit does not want to be a party to corruption but is hesitant to act against his boss. What are the issues involved in the incident that Amit has to consider before acting? Explain options available for Amit to act in this regard.
This case is an example of dilemma between personal interests and interests of the society. Being a public servant, Amit’s priority is towards welfare of public but he is equally concerned about his own position. The actions that Amit should follow should be chosen after careful deliberation and going through various alternatives.
- Various issues involved
- Corruption
The charges against his boss are regarding corruption, which is a serious matter. It is necessary that Amit act without fail.
- Unethical practices
Unethical practices constitute a great misdeed in public service. The move by the boss to indulge in corruption is highly unethical.
- Career goals
Amit, being a fairly new entrant, must take care that his career goals are not affected. He should avoid becoming a victim of vendetta.
- Public interest
Public interest should be paramount in any action that is being carried out. Corruption is a serious impediment for public interest.
- Organizational interests
The issue can bring a bad reputation for the whole organization and also the government. To prevent such problems, it will be necessary to act.
2. Various options available for Amit
- Whistle-blowing
Amit can anonymously bring the issue to public notice so that neither he goes against his moral belief nor he risks his career prospects.
- Delegate the job
Amit can delegate the job to another individual so that he is spared of choosing a difficult option to act against his boss or keep quiet.
- File report with superior
Amit can bypass his boss and can file report directly with higher authority. He can convince them to look into the issue as it pertains to reputation of whole organization.
Thus, choosing the correct option will depend on what matters for Amit. He should balance his personal views and organizational welfare.
Next
previous
Latest News
EDITORIALS & ARTICLES
General Studies